Tout Wars FAAB Report: Week of April 22

Welcome to the weekly Tout Wars FAAB report, on its new home right here on the Tout Wars site. Each week, we’ll review the free agent acquisitions from all five leagues, with commentary from a league member, as well as yours truly. We changed the timing of the weekly run to 1 PM ET every Sunday, with the report posted later that afternoon so you’ll have time to digest and apply to your own leagues. In addition, I’ll be joining Lawr Michaels and Justin Mason on the Tout Wars Hour on the FNTSY Network every Sunday at 3:20 PM ET to discuss the results.

You can find the complete list of Tout Warriors here. Everyone starts with 1000 FAAB units, less any penalty incurred by finishing below a designated point in the standings. This is a means of keeping everyone motivated to keep playing all season long. The minimum bid is $0. FAAB units can be traded as well as rebated for players released off the DL.

The report will list all winning bids along with unsuccessful tries and contingencies. This provides the maximum level of information to help gauge interest on the players.

The American and National League only formats are 12-team leagues, as is the new points-based head to head league, The Mixed Auction and Draft each have 15 clubs. All the leagues have four reserves with an unlimited DL, expect the head to head league, which allows six reserves.

The headings above each league are links to publicly accessible sites where you can see standings, roster and a complete review of transactions. The initial auctions and drafts can be found here.

AMERICAN LEAGUE

SUCCESSFUL BIDS

PLAYER WINNING BID
LGurriel, Tor Vlad Sedler 159 Seth Trachtman 122 Patrick Davitt 39
Rob Leibowitz 16
BColon, Tex Doug Dennis 11 Lawr Michaels 0
RNunez, Tex Rob Leibowitz 9 Vlad Sedler 29 Lawr Michaels 5
Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1
JDiekman, Tex Chris Liss 5
JPeterson, NYY Rob Leibowitz 4
LMaile, Tor Lawr Michaels 3
TraThompson, CWS Seth Trachtman 1 Rob Leibowitz 2 Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1
ChMartin, Tex Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1 Doug Dennis 0
HHembree, Bos Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1 Doug Dennis 0
RGrossman, Min Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1 Seth Trachtman 1
JField, TB Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1 Rob Leibowitz 4
JBarria, LAA Seth Trachtman 1
DOtero, Cle Doug Dennis 0
TClippard, Tor Lawr Michaels 0
DFreitas, Sea Lawr Michaels 0
EGonzalez, Cle Seth Trachtman 0
RPressly, Min Doug Dennis 0

UNAWARDED BIDS

PLAYER
MHernandez, Bos Rob Leibowitz 3
BRondon, CWS Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1
NGoody, Cle Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1
RLaMarre, Min Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 1
TOaks, KC Seth Trachtman 1
CRoe, TB Rick Wolf/Glenn Colton 0
GUrshela, Cle Rob Leibowitz 0
JKelly, Bos Lawr Michaels 0
JPazos, Sea Doug Dennis 0
LSardinas, Bal Seth Trachtman 0

Glenn Colton’s Commentary

There were not a lot of fish in the free agent sea for this week’s Tout Wars AL FAAB fishermen.  Yuli Gurriel’s baby brother Lourdes Gurriel was the big catch when the AL Tout Warriors cast their lines.  Vlad Sedler now owns Gurriel thanks to a big $159 bid.  While Vlad may end being right about his faith in the Jays MI, his fellow owners did not agree Gurriel was worth it.  Indeed, only one other owner bid (Patrick Davitt at $39).  Gurriel has made starts at 2b and SS for the Jays since being called up earlier in the week so there should be playing time while Josh Donaldson and Troy Tulowitzki are on the shelf.  Last year Lourdes struggled in the minors, posting a mere .241 at Double-A but this year in his second go at the level, he raked .347.  In this author’s view, Lourdes Gurriel is a deep-leaguer only as there is little evidence he will contribute much speed or power this year.

Other hitters who went off the board were a selection of guys who were needed mostly to fill holes.  For example, our team, Colton & the Wolfman, found itself very short on OF, so we went fishing in the shallow end and reeled in Johnny Field and Robbie Grossman for $1 each.  Hopefully they will not be needed for very long.

The ageless wonder, Big Sexy himself, Bartolo Colon, was the big pitching fish going for $11 to pitching guru Doug Dennis.  As for us, team Colton & the Wolfman cut bait on some bad starting pitching choosing instead to roster high K relievers Heath Hembree and Chris Martin – both of whom have pitched pretty well thus far this year.

Bottom line: with 8 of the 12 Tout AL teams having 900+ of their 1,000 FAAB still in the bank, it seems owners are trying to position themselves for a run at the midsummer interleague trade talent.

Todd’s Take

I’ve been intrigued by Chris Martin since the spring. The Rangers bullpen is still a bit unsettled with Keone Kela currently copping closing duties. He’s getting by, but not without issued. Kela’s first pitch strike, and overall strike rates are well below league average, especially for a closer.

Martin spent the last couple seasons in Japan, refining his stuff. It seems to have worked as the lanky righty has fanned 10 with just two walked in 10.1 innings. Hit and homers have been an issue, but I’d rather have the solid K and BB skills and hope for regression than rely on a guy with a low BABIP and mediocre skills.

NATIONAL LEAGUE

SUCCESSFUL BIDS

PLAYER WINNING BID
JJeffress, Mil Todd Zola 77 Steve Gardner 22 Scott Wilderman 1
TBlach, SF Lenny Melnick 67 Tristan H. Cockcroft 0
ABlandio, Cin Brian Walton 40 Scott Wilderman 12
ACimber, SD Todd Zola 37 Steve Gardner 10 Scott Wilderman 0
MWisler, Atl Phil Hertz 34 Tristan H. Cockcroft 3 Grey Albright 1
TONeill, StL Todd Zola 33 Brian Walton 25 Mike Gianella 13
Tristan H. Cockcroft 12 Scott Wilderman 1
Steve Gardner 0
MMuncy, LAD Brian Walton 30 Andy Behrens 1
JNottingham, Mil Todd Zola 27
JBautista, Atl Mike Gianella 22
EDiaz, Pit Phil Hertz 13 Todd Zola 17
ELauer, SD Lenny Melnick 9 Tristan H. Cockcroft 3 Phil Hertz 5
DBote, ChC Craig Mish 8
NCuevas, Col Grey Albright 5
KTomlinson, SF Andy Behrens 4 Scott Wilderman 0
JHellickson, Was Tristan H. Cockcroft 3 Phil Hertz 7
JLobaton, NYM Grey Albright 1
KCrick, Pit Steve Gardner 0

UNAWARDED BIDS

PLAYER
PSewald, NYM Todd Zola 43
VArano, Phi Todd Zola 37 Phil Hertz 3
SCarle, Atl Todd Zola 33
BDuensing, ChC Todd Zola 27
JChargois, LAD Todd Zola 23
JMurphy, Ari Todd Zola 23 Grey Albright 1
MMoroff, Pit Brian Walton 20 Andy Behrens 1
TTelis, Mia Brian Walton 20
TNido, NYM Todd Zola 17 Grey Albright 1
MKoch, Ari Phil Hertz 17
CPerez, Atl Todd Zola 13
ERamos, Phi Phil Hertz 3
LGarcia, Phi Phil Hertz 3
PMaton, SD Phil Hertz 3 Grey Albright 1
CGearrin, SF Grey Albright 1
JHughes, Cin Grey Albright 1
PBaez, LAD Grey Albright 1
CPennington, Cin Andy Behrens 1
WChen, Mia Tristan H. Cockcroft 0

Todd’s Commentary and Take

I was the most active bidder, along with submitting the high bid, so I’ll pull double-duty this week. Anchored by Robbie Ray and Luis Castillo, my pitching isn’t off to a great start. Plus, I lost Taijuan Walker, though I get $110 FAAB units back for my $11 auction purchase.

I have faith things will get better, but the bleeding needs to be stopped by jettisoning Kyle Freeland and Brian Mitchell. I still like Mitchell, so he’ll be reserved, but Freeland is off the roster.  The replacements are Jeremy Jeffress and Adam Cimber.

Cimber is getting the job done, pitching a decent number of innings with strikeouts. With Petco Park at his back, I’ll take my chances.

This just in – Craig Counsell doesn’t care about your (or my) fantasy team. I’m at the point I suspect he asks his relievers to pick a number 1 to 100 and whichever is closest gets to close that night. I don’t need saves with three closers (Brad Boxberger, Brandon Morrow and Arodys Vizcaino but maybe another save or two from Jeffress will facilitate a trade down the line. My bigger concern is innings and whiffs, which he’s providing.

Needing someone to replace Walker, I opted for a stick since I was using an arm in the swing spot. I have no idea how much Tyler O’Neil will play, but there’s no reason to be miserly with FAAB since I’m playing with the short stack. As it turns out, I could have just activated David Dahl into swing, but I’m OK with using both Dahl and O’Neill while sending Juan Lagares to the bench.

On draft day, securing Stephen Vogt and Manny Pina on the cheap seemed genius. The best laid plans. Pina is due back, but I wanted a hedge. Nottingham is perfect since he’ll play even when Pina is back plus if Pina doesn’t make it back, Nottingham will play even more. Tout rules allow mid-week activation of players coming off the DL so long as you release the active player he replaces. With Jeff Mathis as my second catcher, I’m not concerned.

Enough about me…

Lenny Melnick is hoping Ty Blach takes advantage of a two-start week at home in AT&T and the Giants entertain a couple of last season’s NL playoff clubs with the Nationals and Dodgers coming to town. Both lineups are dangerous, but sluggish to open the season. Aiding Blach’s cause is Anthony Rendon finally hitting the DL over the weekend.

The Reds have been scuffling for s fill-in at the hot corner while Eugenio Suarez is on the shelf. Too bad they don’t have a can’t-miss third baseman prospect in the wings. Cliff Pennington got first shot, now it’s Alex Blandino’s turn. Brian Walton hopes Blandino can continue his modest three-game hitting streak.

MIXED LEAGUE AUCTION 

SUCCESSFUL BIDS

PLAYER WINNING BID
MWilliamson, SF Fred Zinkie 94 Ron Shandler 57 Tim McLeod 43
Al Melchior 13
TCahill, Oak Jeff Zimmerman 54 Al Melchior 37 Ron Shandler 11
Bret Sayre 6
MCanha, Oak Jeff Zimmerman 54 Ron Shandler 37 Al Melchior 0
JJones, Det Ron Shandler 47 Bret Sayre 16 Fred Zinkie 13
Al Melchior 1
CBettis, Col Fred Zinkie 43 Al Melchior 15 Tim McLeod 1
Jeff Zimmerman 0
DSpan, TB Fred Zinkie 43 Bret Sayre 16
MMoreland, Bos Zach Steinhorn 43
JVargas, NYM Scott Engel 41 Fred Zinkie 23
BColon, Tex Scott Engel 31 Scott Engel 33 Ron Shandler 3
LGurriel, Tor Al Melchior 27
AFrazier, Pit Ray Flowers 17
ACashner, Bal Al Melchior 15
MWisler, Atl Ron Shandler 11 Jeff Zimmerman 0
AAlmora, ChC Tim McLeod 11 Al Melchior 1
TomHunter, Phi Tim McLeod 8
AWainwright, StL Bret Sayre 6 Jeff Zimmerman 0
SRodriguez, Pit Ron Shandler 5
BPhillips, Mil Ron Shandler 2
JBandy, Mil Scott Pianowski 0
EHernandez, LAD Bret Sayre 0

UNAWARDED BIDS

PLAYER
AdGonzalez, NYM Zach Steinhorn 32
JarGarcia, Mia Scott Engel 31 Tim McLeod 5
MKoch, Ari Scott Engel 21
MFiers, Det Scott Engel 19
SPearce, Tor Fred Zinkie 13
YHirano, Ari Tim McLeod 7
JTomlin, Cle Bret Sayre 6 Jeff Zimmerman 0
RDavis, Cle Tim McLeod 3
JFields, LAD Tim McLeod 2
HBader, StL Ron Shandler 1
JHammel, KC Ron Shandler 1
JProfar, Tex Ron Shandler 1
NHundley, SF Scott Pianowski 0
PSewald, NYM Scott Engel 0
CFulmer, CWS Jeff Zimmerman 0
KFreeland, Col Jeff Zimmerman 0
MMoore, Tex Jeff Zimmerman 0
SRomano, Cin Jeff Zimmerman 0
TBlach, SF Jeff Zimmerman 0
JCamargo, Atl Al Melchior 0

Jeff Zimmerman’s Commentary

It was a bland week for bidding in the mixed auction league. Most teams were just filling needs with Williamson, Canha, Jones, and Span in the outfield. For starters, Cahill, Bettis, Vargas, and Colon were the top bids. Toronto prospect, Lourdes Gurriel was taken for just $27. No one was too aggressive. The one move I like a little further down the list is Adam Frazier at $17. Frazier should slot right into DLed Josh Harrison’s role with the Pirates
With the 2nd and 3rd highest bids, I picked up Mark Canha and Trevor Cahill. While I overbid a bit on each one, I wanted them both, so I got them. With Cahill, I’m getting two starts from a pitcher who dominated the White Sox (whoopie). I know he could hurt my ratios but since I’m last in both ERA and WHIP, I might as well roll the dice with him.
With Canha, I’m hoping he’s as productive as he was in 2016. With hitters, I find they are already owned before owners can be 100% sure the breakout is legit. I’ll own him first and then see if his gains in plate discipline and hard contact stick.

Todd’s Take

Could Mac Williamson be the next entry into the Launch Angle Club? I’d ask him, but the first rule of the…you know the rest.

Williamson spent time with Doug Latta in the off-season. Previously, Latta refined Justin Turner’s approach and stroke and so far, it appears Williamson’s time was well spent. He slashed an eye-popping .487/.600/.1.026 top open the season at Triple-A Sacramento, forcing the Giants hand. There’s an opening with Hunter Pence out, but it wouldn’t take much for Williamson to secure playing time when Pence returns.

MIXED LEAGUE DRAFT

SUCCESSFUL BIDS

PLAYER WINNING BID
ChVillanueva, SD Scott White 104 Michael Beller 78 Anthony Perri 56
Rudy Gamble 23 D.J. Short 22
Tom Kessenich 6
JFields, LAD Anthony Perri 53
JJones, Det Tom Kessenich 36 Perry Van Hook 6
MWilliamson, SF Scott White 34 Scott White 64 Joe Pisapia 26
Greg Ambrosius 13
BMcCarthy, Atl Michael Beller 33 D.J. Short 20 Greg Ambrosius 13
Jeff Boggis 12 Perry Van Hook 11
Adam Ronis 8 Scott White 0
TWilliams, Pit Anthony Perri 32
MWisler, Atl Anthony Perri 23 Perry Van Hook 3
FGalvis, SD Gene McCaffrey 18 Tom Kessenich 2
TCahill, Oak Greg Ambrosius 17 Joe Pisapia 34 Scott White 0
RFlaherty, Atl Jeff Boggis 12 Tom Kessenich 3
CBettis, Col Jeff Boggis 12 Jeff Boggis 11 Perry Van Hook 7
AWainwright, StL Jeff Boggis 10
BNimmo, NYM Greg Ambrosius 9
DSpan, TB Perry Van Hook 7 Tom Kessenich 13
JPederson, LAD Ray Murphy 4
AdGonzalez, NYM Tom Kessenich 4
JJimenez, Det Adam Ronis 4
CSpangenberg, SD Rudy Gamble 3
PSeverino, Was Anthony Perri 2

UNAWARDED BIDS

PLAYER
AAlmora, ChC Joe Pisapia 6
SPearce, Tor Tom Kessenich 4 Perry Van Hook 2
MBoyd, Det Adam Ronis 4
HPerez, Mil Gene McCaffrey 3
MCanha, Oak Perry Van Hook 2
PAlvarez, Bal Tom Kessenich 2
CAsuaje, SD Gene McCaffrey 1
JJay, KC Rudy Gamble 1

Ray Murphy’s Commentary

A lot of activity today in Mixed-Draft, with 12 of 15 teams working the free agent pool. But it’s mostly speculative plays or tweaking around the roster edges, as we had only one triple-digit bid (Christian Villanueva, won by Scott White with a bid of 103), and only one more over 50 (Josh Fields, won by Anthony Perri for 53). The other 17 players were all acquired for 36 units or less.

My acquisition was Joc Pederson. I was in the market for some OF depth, with Byron Buxton and Carlos Gonzalez banged up, and Wil Myers not yet OF-eligible. Pederson got some more playing time this week and showed some signs of life at the plate. Most noteworthy is that, so far, he is carrying over his late-2017 gains in contact rate. If that trend holds, he could work his way back into regular AB in the still-crowded Dodger OF.

Todd’s Take

If you don’t subscribe to The Athletic, think about it, if only to get Eno Sarris’ work (there’s other great stuff as well). It’s Eno’s story to tell, but this week, he featured six pitchers with a new weapon, one being Brandon McCarthy throwing what he calls a second slider, along with a curve and cutter. The differences in velocity, break and depth are working. With McCarthy’s injury history, get in while the getting’s good.

I’d be willing to bet half what’s left of my FAAB Wiseguy Gene McCaffrey bid on Freddy Galvis for his early week visit to Coors Field. As a challenge game player, Gene is wired to look for these sorts of things. You should too.

HEAD-TO-HEAD MIXED AUCTION

SUCCESSFUL BIDS

PLAYER WINNING BID
DSwanson, Atl Stephania Bell 127 Michael Rathburn 36 Andrea LaMont 31
ChVillanueva, SD Michael Rathburn 56 Paul Sporer 36 Peter Kreutzer 23
Justin Mason 5 Jake Ciely 2
MWisler, Atl Andrea LaMont 41 Peter Kreutzer 37
TRoss, SD Jake Ciely 39 Peter Kreutzer 11
CBettis, Col Peter Kreutzer 37 Dr. Roto 26 Michael Rathburn 9
ADiaz, Tor Andrea LaMont 33 Justin Mason 5
MBoyd, Det Andrea LaMont 27 Stephania Bell 11 Dr. Roto 6
MAndujar, NYY Peter Kreutzer 23 Jake Ciely 2
CKuhl, Pit Howard Bender 22 Michael Rathburn 6
TCahill, Oak Howard Bender 22 Jake Ciely 39 Paul Sporer 16
Michael Rathburn 16 Peter Kreutzer 13
Clay Link 4
FLiriano, Det Peter Kreutzer 17
BNorris, StL Dr. Roto 10
MCanha, Oak Andrea LaMont 7 Peter Kreutzer 0
CVazquez, Bos Jake Ciely 4
DSpan, TB Peter Kreutzer 3 Justin Mason 0
JPCrawford, Phi Jake Ciely 2
JHeyward, ChC Justin Mason 0 Peter Kreutzer 2
CGranderson, Tor Justin Mason 0

UNAWARDED BIDS

PLAYER
AAlmora, ChC Michael Rathburn 24 Peter Kreutzer 1
JJones, Det Michael Rathburn 24 Andrea LaMont 0
ACashner, Bal Howard Bender 22
JarGarcia, Mia Andrea LaMont 14
SPearce, Tor Peter Kreutzer 3 Justin Mason 0
RFlaherty, Atl Andrea LaMont 3 Peter Kreutzer 0
DMengden, Oak Peter Kreutzer 0
LValbuena, LAA Peter Kreutzer 0
MRojas, Mia Peter Kreutzer 0

Peter Kreutzer’s Commentary

In the early going, finding FAABable players isn’t hard. Knowing what to bid for them can be a challenge. Stephania Bell’s team wasn’t performing, partly because Brandon Crawford is off to a bad start. Dansby Swanson was gleaming in the free agent pool, and Bell grabbed him for $127. There were two other bidders, both in the $30, but Bell needed a SS, and paid for him.
Michael Rathburn wanted Christian Villanueva, who has not calmed down. He put in a bid of $56 and grabbed the surprising slugger, who did attract a $36 bid from Paul Sporer, who was looking to replace Ohtani Hitter.
For my part, I needed a 3B because Josh Donaldson is hurt and Brian Anderson, after a nice start, has cooled off quite a bit. I ranked Miguel Andujar a notch ahead of Villanueva and nabbed him for $23.
On the pitching side of things, it was a challenge to rank this week’s starters.
Bell: Boyd
Bender: Cahill, Kuhl, Cashner
Sporer: Cahill
Dr, Roto: Bettis, reliever Norris, Boyd
Rathburn: Cahill, Bettis, Kuhl
LaMont: Wisler, Boyd, Jar Garcia
Ciely: Ross, Cahill
Link: Cahill
Kreutzer: Bettis, Wisler, Liriano, Cahill, Mengden, Ross.
Lamont’s $41 beat out my $37 for Wisler. I ended up with Bettis and Liriano. I should feel good about that, right?
Todd’s Take
Talking with Justin Mason on the Tout Wars Hour on FNTSY Network this week, he mentioned difficulties dealing a closer. Keep in mind this is a points league so he’s trading points, not saves. It’s going to be fun to follow how some of the Touts adjust to the scoring once a few week’s are in the books.